Conference Call
Tuesday, March 6, 2012
I went to Chicago last week for AWP, which is a conference of writers, and one thing I should tell you up front is that "conference of writers" is, for me, analogous to "the ninth circle of hell." I didn't go to be a writer; I went for my job--for one of my jobs; I have a lot of jobs, these days. I stayed in a fancy hotel with a lot of businessmen. The hotel elevators had mirrors in them and a little television screen that scrolled the day's headlines. On my second morning in Chicago I got in the elevator with a businessman who held the door for me and then tried very hard not to look at me, and the headlines on the tiny television screen were "Hundreds of Wolves Killed" and "Fetal Personhood Bill Passes Oklahoma Senate." It was before eight in the morning and I started to cry, for the next twenty floors, wiping at my eyes and hoping the businessman wouldn't notice. He held the door for me again at the lobby without looking at my face.
At AWP I was trying to tell people about the personhood bill but, you know, no one wants to hear that shit at a bookfair. No one wants to hear about my body. No one believes it will actually happen, except that it is happening. It is happening now. I felt like I was in one of those dreams where you are trying to warn people about something important but your mouth won't open. That bitch just doesn't know when to shut up. Sometimes people didn't know what I was talking about; "Personhood of what?" someone said to me, and I gave up and went into the bathroom and locked myself in a stall and cried some more. The bathroom had started to smell pretty awful by the second day--there were something like eleven thousand people there, I don't think the Hilton was really prepared. I don't want to feel like this all the time. I understand it is not comfortable for other people to be around me, to be around the bitch who will not shut up. I don't want to be the person wandering around the marble lobby of the Chicago Hilton having a fucking panic attack because no one feels like home to me, because I do not ever want to talk to anyone about whether I am a writer again, because right now, right fucking now, every fucking right I have is being stripped away from me, is being stripped away from people I care about, and no one seems to fucking care; but here I am, that person. I tried to meet people; I did a pretty good job, for me. I lost count of the number of people who came up to me and took my hand and gazed into my eyes and said, "It's so good to see you again," and when I stared at them in terror added gently, "You remember, we met last year," and each one of them seemed so genuinely pleased that I did not have the heart to tell them I have never been to AWP in my life.
On the second night I went to a poetry reading at a hot-dog restaurant with some people from my work. It was a fast-food sort of place. Three employees of the hot-dog restaurant stood behind the counter, watching all the white people file in and read poems about trees or dildos or whatever. Language experiments. I probably don't need to tell you that the hot-dog restaurant employees were black, but I'll tell you anyway. In situations like that I want to do something, to clearly demonstrate that I am on the side of the help--you know, climb over the counter, spray down the dish pit. Like that would somehow alter the balance of everything that is fucked-up in the world. The poetry reading went on forever and the room got hotter and hotter and I went outside and stood on the sidewalk with the people from my work. We passed around a bottle of whiskey and talked about how fucked-up it was. I guess it made us feel better about ourselves, that we had noticed the palpably obvious. I couldn't understand the purpose of poetry in that moment, couldn't understand what there was to care about. The poems were fine and some of them were even good but all I could think about was the people who worked there, leaning up against the counter, waiting for us to leave. Later I found out that one of the hot-dog restaurant employees had been there since five in the morning, that she would have to be there again, the next morning, to open. When I went back to the hotel that night I got in the elevator with a different businessman--I think it was a different one; maybe not. They all look the same. I was wearing my favorite gloves, the ones with the skeleton hands on them. Both the businessman and I were very drunk. "Jesus," said the businessman. "Those are some awful gloves."
I had a drink one night with my friend Bojan, who lives in Phoenix--Bojan Louis, that is a name I want you to remember, because that dude is going to be a big fucking deal--and we were talking about the book bannings in Arizona and how lost we felt at AWP, surrounded by people who were going about their business as if nothing was wrong, tenured and placid. "I'm not interested in language anymore," I said, "unless it's doing the work of revolution," and it was one of those things I didn't know was true until I said it and then when I said it I knew it had been true, for me, all along. "It can still be beautiful," Bojan said, and I said, "I want it to always be beautiful." And that's it, that's what I want: I want beauty that remakes the world. When I make jokes about guillotines people get uncomfortable but you know, I'm not really joking anymore, is the thing. I know how that one ended but look around you. Look around you and tell me you don't want guillotines a little, too. Tell me you don't want language that is a shear, cutting through; tell me you don't want words that leave the streets running with blood. Bojan gave a talk the next morning at the Indigenous Writers' Caucus and the moderator, LeAnne Howe, started out by taking off her gloves and slapping them against the podium, shouting, "I'm throwing down the gauntlet!" and I thought Oh my god, finally, finally we are talking about it, and we did. Talked about making language into a weapon. Talked about fighting, about never giving in--you know who knows about fighting in the face of impossible odds, about never giving in in this country? The indigenous people of the Americas, that's for fucking sure. "Personhood is something the Choctaw Nation could have used in Oklahoma a long time ago," is one of the things that LeAnne Howe said. Bojan read, read about being an electrician, about the movement of currents, of power, about the banning of stories, about working ten-hour days and watching the undocumented workers laboring alongside him get deported at the end of the workday, about how fucking angry and tired he is, all of us are, and it was--I don't even have the words for what it was. That language, terrible and gorgeous and necessary, a knife cutting me open; I am thinking now of those tools that split apart your ribcage and leave bare what's inside. This, I thought, this is fucking poetry, crying openly this time, letting it go, getting ready. Our anger is how we find each other, how we make a place that is ours. You'll know me in the street by the rage I live with, by the rage I will not hide.
Thanks for this. The more I read about that shit--personhood, contraception "debates", etc--the angrier I get, the more I doubt my writing because what's the point? It's nice to be reminded.
Now I am maudlin. Also, I want some skeleton gloves. How come only my son gets those?
http://www.starpathvisions.com/Pluto%20n%20Capricorn.html i sent your post to my 66 yr old friend don..he feels so alone with all this he screams at how no one seems to care.. that's him writing about it at this link .. thanks
I hear you, and I understand. I'm down about a lot of stuff, too. The national election in November is super critical.
I've been in this mood since last winter, when I stood up from reading yet another news article that carved a little bit out of my heart, drove to the state capitol, and met up with 100,000 other people who were all gathering together in the same spirit. It was something I think about when I get black-cloud-of-doom-discouraged. There are people out there that I would actually connect with, people who feel the same wounds I do, when so many seem to ignore the bleeding and the suffering all around them, even in them, because it hasn't gone deep enough yet.
(And I used to play cello with a guy named Bojan back in seventh grade, but I don't think it's the same one.)
Your comment about the hot dog restaurant reminds me of a scene from an amazing play written in Boston by a talented black woman named Lydia Diamond.
The play itself is about a black family living on Nantucket (a fact many people never understood that there was a black community on such a wealthy island even before the civil rights movement). One of the characters brings home his white girlfriend. During the scene in question, she's speaking to the daughter of the family's housekeeper (who is a housekeeper herself and is filling in for her mother during the course of the play).
The white character tries not to "use" the housekeeper, because she felt it was demeaning for a black person to be in a servile role. But in truth, a truth that the young housekeeper exposes with cutting accuracy, it's the job itself that the white woman had a problem with. To translate it to your own experience, you're pitying black people for working at a hot dog stand because you think a hot dog stand is beneath you and thus beneath them. It doesn't matter if they work hard or do well. Without knowing them or knowing their character, you see their situation and you judge them. Your guilt is just an evolved sense of prejudice.
The play has moved on to New York. If you have a chance to see it, it's called Stick Fly and it will blow your mind.
Unfortunately the election won't change anything. The only chance for change is if a lot more people get this same spirit of resistance in the face of injustice. It's hard to keep the anger without it calcifying into cynicism and despair.
That's something that's always been integral to me, too, I think---that I'm not interested in language unless it's doing the work of revolution. I can't imagine being any other way.
Hey Joseph, I have literally cleaned other people's shit for a living, so I don't take kindly to that comment.
It wasn't this evil when feminism started. I don't understand why this is happening now. It seems so obvious to me that almost anything that benefits women also benefits society. Don't Republicans see that? If it's not obvious to them that they've already fatally shot themselves in the foot re the election, then yes, bring on the guillotines. If we're going to lose the little we've gained, then screw it. And this goes for people of color and sexual orientation and wolves and all that. I'm not standing up only for women. Some people in this country are going crazy and trying to drag the rest of us down with them. We have to stop them.
As a person, I want guillotines more than just a little. How can we be anything but furious?
As a father, I'm afraid of revolution. I was at the WTO riot in '99, and I saw what martial law did to the children.
I can't really talk about it. Not here, not now.
Roar, honey. Roar.
This. THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS.
Beauty that remakes the world. Truth.
Experimental poetry/"language experiments" ... I guess if no one does it then we won't know it sucks. Still. Blargh.
You know who you should read? Sherman Alexie. His essays are very "I'm gonna tell it like it is."
My discomfort with things like this comes neither from pity nor judgment. It comes from knowing that the playing field will never be level, not between races or genders or neighborhoods or any two people. It comes from wondering if someone else with a crappier lot in life could have taken my semi-decent lot and done more with it, accomplished things, made the world a better place.
Long-time lurker and admirer of your writing, but this post punched me in the gut. I was with you on that first elevator, and in that hot-dog stand poetry reading, experiencing the awful, lonely dissonance of a world going about its shallow business, while real, bloody, outrageous injustice is howling outside, and ignored. And yes to that restaurant worker, and yes to Bojan, and yes to LeAnne Howe, and yes to you to be seen and heard and reckoned with. Thank you for writing this and tearing me open a bit today.
Well said. I remember thinking at the Caucus that there was an earnest energy (to skid right past the obvious beauty) in the room that had been missing in all of my other experiences at AWP. The MFA world can often feel hollow in a similar, language-over-matter kind of way, as if the feat of poem-making is more important than the poem. And I don't mean to say I lament our value of craft; I mean that what often matters most is the presentation of some linguistic feat, which almost always ends up being solely that-- a presentation, a performance that begs for applause rather than any kind of emotional movement or real change. Your post has rev'd up my energy to face my next week here with a more resilient and shit-resistant attitude. So thanks for that (and thanks to Bojan, for showing me your blog).
Also, as a side-rage-note, I've been confronted on ASU's campus lately with blown-up posters of unborn fetuses, as if that were any kind of sophisticated visual argument. SEE FETUS, FEEL ASHAMED. Great place to confuse some scared and pregnant teenagers, these college campuses. Le sigh.
Come to Canada, Rejectionist. Our cells are just cells, ourselves just ourselves, and it never really gets hot.
Oh man, in Canada you have Stephen Harper, though. Sigh. NOWHERE IS SAFE UNTIL WE REVOLT
Yeah...the whole openly-evil-leader thing is sort of the elephant in the room up here...
Here in Texas, a few short Tuesdays ago, they began enforcing a law requiring doctors to perform intrauterine ultrasounds on women seeking LEGAL abortions. The women may turn their heads away from the screens, but then the doctor is required to verbally describe the physical characteristics of the fetus. Since research has shown that ultrasounds do not alter the decision to have an abortion, this is a strictly punitive measure - it is the legal authorization of physical and emotional abuse against women who are seeking a legal medical procedure. On that Tuesday, I was so sad and so outraged, and I got on the Eff-book excpecting that other people would be sad and outraged...and...Silence. The only light for me came when my 17-year-old son came to me tearfully after reading The Handmaid's Tale, saying, "Mom, these are scary times." So I'm not completely alone. Thank you for your rage.
Oh, man. Don't get me started. The key, for me, is trying to live with rage that doesn't consume me. It's not easy.
Beautiful post. Rage on. Experience joy.
I just found your blog today, and I'm not usually one to comment on blogs - I wish I did comment more often, I wish I felt inspired to comment more often. But this time is different, and I am so glad to be reading what you write. Your confidence and lack of inhibition in saying what you want to say is inspiring. I've been trying for ages to find an outlet and the words to express similar outrages, because it seems like no one is angry enough, but I always find myself reigning it in or worrying about offense. To read someone really using words and firing off shots with them...I'm excited, and I will definitely be coming back. And maybe I'll throw my voice in, too, because everything you're saying needs to be said over and over again and a hundred times as loud until it can't be ignored any longer.
Thank you.
Post a Comment