sometimes nothing can be a real cool hand
About

1.
Lisbeth Salander is always willing to fuck you. That's what makes her Lisbeth Salander. You know it, from the first page. Everything else is just icing on the cake.

2.
My old boss used to compare me to Lisbeth Salander. My old boss never understood why I did not take this as a compliment. After all, Lisbeth Salander is hot. "Not that you're a sociopath!" she would say. "Just, you know, you're thin, and you have so many tattoos. And your clothes." If I remember correctly--it's been a long time, since I read the Lisbeth Salander book--Lisbeth Salander only has one tattoo, a dragon, placed in a becoming manner upon her bony shoulder. Lisbeth Salander definitely does not have a stick-and-poke banner (empty) from the night she drank a fifth of Wild Turkey with her friend Matt and decided to commemorate the occasion, or a procession of wobbly broken hearts up the inside of her calf from the time she let her friend's ex-junkie lover practice on her with his new tattoo gun. Lisbeth Salander does not have her dead cat's name inside a heart over her hip, or a flight of shorebirds winging their way from her knees to her hipbones--the first tattoo I paid real money for, and the best tattoo I have ever seen, if I do say so myself. Stick and poke banners: not sexy. At all. Believe me. It's tiny, at least. My old boss used to compare me to Lisbeth Salander, and then she would make me go get her coffee. Small latte, not too hot, two sugars. Look at me: I still remember.

3.
Lisbeth Salander is skinny. Frail-skinny, bird-boned skinny, so that when you fuck Lisbeth Salander you think: Not so tough. I could break you. Fuckable damaged girls are always skinny in books by men; fat girls are a different kind of damaged. Which is to say, unlovable. Remember that, the next time you tell someone Lisbeth Salander is strong.

4.
Here's what most women I know who have been raped did to the person who raped them: Nothing. There's not much you can do. If there were, most women I know probably wouldn't have been raped. I worked once, more than ten years ago now, with a woman who shot her abuser. She's still in jail. He's fine.

5.
You're the only one who sees it, the woman inside the monster. Like Beauty and the Beast. Give her a rose and she's yours. Lisbeth Salander will never look for the beauty in herself. That's your job, tiger.

6.
The posters are up for the Lisbeth Salander movie. They're everywhere, in all the subway tunnels. Not the famously controversial one, where Lisbeth Salander is naked and gazes defiantly at the camera as James Bond grabs her boobs. This one is just the side of her head, with James Bond inside it. I don't think it's supposed to be symbolic, that there's a dude in there.

7.
The Lisbeth Salander clothes store on Gansevoort is only open for three days. I went yesterday, the first day. It was full of Italian girls in Uggs. The store has a fake library and flashing lights and a dj. Real comprehensive look. In New York they call this a curated environment. I got some pretty sick plastic pants even though I keep telling myself no more sweatshop clothes. They're not very well-made. I'm kind of thinking about going back today and getting another pair, for when they fall apart. Is that weird? Maybe that's weird. It's just that they look so good.

8.
Lisbeth Salander is not an actual person, although she reminds me a lot of Lara Croft.

9.
Lisbeth Salander is crazy, Lisbeth Salander is broken. Lisbeth Salander doesn't know kindness. Until you come along. You. Yes, you. Lisbeth Salander is waiting for you, to show her the mysteries of her own heart. Lisbeth Salander: incomplete without you. You'll find yourself attracted to her, despite her prickly demeanor; underneath it all, she's really rather pretty, although she doesn't think so. Tell her she's a babe! She'll growl, but secretly she'll be pleased. There's a soft spot in there, just waiting for you to find it. Draw it out, with your compassion. Feed her a square meal. Lisbeth Salander is a stray you can take home. Pick the burrs out of her matted coat and brush her until her fur shines. Lisbeth Salander is cleverer than you but by the end of the book that won't matter. Lisbeth Salander just needs to fall in love. You--yes, you--can be the only man who makes her real.

10.
I've known some strong women. Feral, my friend Dirt's forest-activist girlfriend, who u-locked herself by the neck to a bulldozer on a forest stand that was about to be clearcut and lived on a platform in the trees for months at a time. Later she went to work on the Greenpeace boat and after that she sailed around the world. I had a brief delusional moment where I considered forest activism, until Dirt told me you have to poop in a bucket. In front of other people. That's the thing about the platform: You can't come down. My friend NoƩlia, who grew up in the middle of the desert with a dad who beat the shit out of her and brothers who did other, worse things, who was hooked on meth by the time she was fifteen, which is around when she met the boyfriend who spent the next ten years trying to kill her. Now she is a lawyer who does pro bono work for undocumented women; in her free time, she started a social justice organization. My friends who have hopped trains alone across the country, hitchhiked solo from Alaska to Tierra del Fuego, bicycled alone from Morocco to Ulaan Bataar, my friends who are social workers and activists and artists and revolutionaries and lovers and fighters, fighters, fighters. Me. Not to toot my own horn, but I am pretty fucking strong. I guess "Is awesome, loves self, probably won't have sex with you" would make for a pretty short book, though. Or at least, not a compelling one. Because it wouldn't be about men.

11.
My friend Meg and I are looking for an intern, to go see the Lisbeth Salander movie and take screenshots of Lisbeth Salander's clothes. Not during the rape or torture scenes, please. If you're interested, let me know.

Ellen said...

Agreed... Though I was glad that, at the very least, she didn't stay with the protag at the end. Because that's what I thought was going to happen, and that would've made it all the worse. I mean, for the next 2 books he's still all condescending and "here, let me help you, I am the only person who understands you poor broken thing," but at least after the first book she's mostly like "fuck off."

December 15, 2011 11:54 AM
Anonymous said...

I love you for this.

I read the first Lisbeth book for my first meeting of a book club at my work. Trying to discuss the book was frustrating, to say the least. I had to quit that book club. I can't believe I even read that torture-porn piece of misogynist crap.

And didn't every lady in the book want to fuck the dude-guy? The whole thing really was just the worst.

December 15, 2011 12:28 PM
Hart Johnson said...

There are a lot of things i really love about Lisbeth. I love that she is smart and determined and stubborn and can plot revenge well. I don't even mind that she will have sex with just about anybody. I came of age in the 80s. I sort of identify. But I agree with your assessment on the masterbation that Mikhail Blokvist was for the author--a man 'making whole' of someone so damaged (and the fact that every woman in the book seemed to want him) was irritating and did indeed make it a male oriented book. I still enjoyed the series though.

Note: she did have a bunch of tattoos--in fact she had one removed between the first and second to help keep people from recognizing her as she was in hiding (the wasp on her neck)

December 15, 2011 2:41 PM
Kate said...

Does it sound weird to say that I guessed most of this from reading the title and the cover blurb? Books by men about "girls" who are actually adult women already have several strikes against them by my count.

December 15, 2011 2:48 PM
Bryan Russell said...

@ Kate

Luckily, those books were written by "boys", and the actual men are somewhere else, engaged in real relationships with adult women. We forgot to send the memo to the boys, though, so these things keep happening.

Memo to self: buy more post-it notes.

December 15, 2011 3:50 PM
Rockaby said...

Ok then.
What IS the standard for accepting a man into ones damaged life?
If it's not loyalty and tenderness I don't know what it is.

Lisbeth has been an inspiration to me, that I'm allowed to fight back against the horrible things in my life. That I'm allowed to love a man who actually fucking earns it.

Yes, most women who are raped don't do anything. But perhaps that's precisely because we've had precious few examples of women fighting back. Society tells us to grin and bare it. To treat rape as a necessary evil of living in this age. To follow "proper" channels in seeking revenge, channels designed and maintained by men for the protection of men.

Before Lisbeth I literally didn't know that fighting back was an option. Before Lisbeth I didn't know how strong I was.
And there are thousands of girls like me drawing strength and inspiration from this character because there are ZERO examples of this kind of strength anywhere else in popular media.

And yes, her ability to accept Mikael IS a kind of strenght... It's a struggle that mirrors a lot of the damaged trust that women have to rebuilt for the right person.
Without that kind of strength the character would undermine herself.

I'm sure the author recognized that. You don't write this kind of book for men alone.

But that doesn't even matter.
For me, TGWTDT isn't about men at all. In fact it's so little about men that Mikael's character and the fact that the author is male is down right superfluous.

The message is "You are strong enough."
And fuck anyone who nitpicks to try to undermine that message.

December 15, 2011 3:51 PM
JenniferWriter said...

#3 and #10 made me cheer--not because I LIKE them but because it feels so good when someone else says the things you are thinking. So, thank you!

December 15, 2011 4:36 PM
Gayle Carline said...

Le R, I admire you.

December 15, 2011 5:18 PM
schietree said...

This reminds me of 'The Hour of the Star' by Brazilian writer Clarice Lispector. All about a frail, beautiful unloved girl from the slums...being described by the male author who is creating her (and the whole thing written by a woman, in case the 'Clarice' part didn't give anything away. It's so amazing and weird and likely everything these 'girl who did something silly' books are not.

December 15, 2011 6:37 PM
Laurel said...

I like revenge stories. Haven't done TGWTDT yet because I dread those first few chapters, but I suspect I will like it. I also suspect some of the eleven thoughts cited here will cross my mind and some of them will bother me enormously.

In a completely unfair, I haven't read the book but lots of the hype and therefore have drawn conclusions sort of way, I don't see LIsbeth being all that very much like LeR. For one thing, I don't picture Lisbeth ever having a cat named LolaPants.

December 15, 2011 9:06 PM
kat said...

so freaking good. i get squicky when i think about the books because they are SO CLUELESS-DUDE (and, you know, "clueless, dude") and so conflicted. (there was like some serious relishing-of-detail in those torture and rape scenes, you know?) but in a weird way, i still love Lisbeth and was fascinated by her. i had the sense that her "inventor" created something that managed to elude and puzzle him and he would've spent the whole series of books trying to figure her out. surrounding her with a lot of idiocy and bad writing, of course, but i think there is something anarchic in her makeup that fascinates. anarchy and female characters don't often get conjoined, i think, except as maybe "sexy psycho-crazy bitch that would've been played by beatrice dalle in a french movie" anarchy.

i actually really, really hoped a female director would've gotten TGWTDT as a project, because it would have been interesting to see the Lisbeth character wielded by a woman, and/or a feminist who wasn't trying to convince himself every woman wanted to sleep with him. and, as a writer, i admit feeling like, "WHY DIDN'T I INVENT LISBETH SALANDER?!!!!" i admit this. i ain't ashamed!

December 15, 2011 10:52 PM
Matthew MacNish said...

Personally, and keep in mind I've only read the first two out of three (maybe four), I really liked Lisbeth, until she slept with Blomkvist. I kept reading, though. Then, she got a boob job. That may be why I haven't read the third one.

December 16, 2011 12:20 PM
Marjorie said...

"I guess 'Is awesome, loves self, probably won't have sex with you' would make for a pretty short book, though. Or at least, not a compelling one. Because it wouldn't be about men." I disagree with you there. This subject matter would make a very compelling book, but sexist men wouldn't want to read it. Unfortunately, they control the publishing industry and a lot of other media. It's up to us to fight back.

December 16, 2011 12:24 PM
Matthew MacNish said...

Also, I think Blomkvist is a pretty obvious example of author insertion. He basically has the exact same backstory as Stieg Larsson.

December 16, 2011 12:25 PM
Anonymous said...

This is lovely and a really great summary of everything I found frustrating and insulting about the book.

December 16, 2011 4:43 PM
Kathleen said...

I hate to disagree with you.
You wrote a good post and I am glad you said these things. #3 especially made me think.
FWIW, I had a different experience reading LS ( than #1, #5, #9.) I certainly didn't get that the author saw her as someone who had a "secret soft spot" just waiting for the right man (author/male reader) to come along. More to the point, that is not how *I* read her. I don't know how to say it without sounding cliched, and I am sure you've heard this before in response to your comments on the books, but I found it very moving/empowering to read about a female character who doesn't take shit from people. Why aren't we all beating up dudes on the subway who think they have a right to our bodies?
When she kicked the shit out of those two bikers, that was one of the most satisfying reading experiences I have ever had.
Anyways, not to reinvent an internet debate that has been had a whole bunch of times....

December 16, 2011 5:06 PM
Matthew MacNish said...

Le R, methinks you need to invent a bit of sarcasm clarifying punctuation. Sometimes it's very easy to miss in writing.

I nominate the ~oh so popular~ tilde.

December 16, 2011 5:07 PM
wondering said...

Hmmm. I read the Lizbeth Sanders series out of order. The first one I read was The Girl Who Played With Fire. The one in which she appears to be lesbian, hates and avoids the narrator, and viciously hunts down men who are kidnapping, raping, and otherwise harming other women. The guy (the boxer) who witnesses an abduction gets involved to help rescue another human being who he has boxed with and respects and not because he just really wants to "fuck that chick". The narrator tries to be a hero, but gets there after the bulk of the action is over and is relegated to a subordinate mop-up role.

Puts a whole different spin on the reading of the series.

December 16, 2011 6:44 PM
Anonymous said...

I am so grateful for this post. It breaks my heart that so many people saw this woman as an "empowered" heroine. It is clear the author knew nothing about rape, nothing about its horrific aftereffects and nothing about the healing process. The author used rape as a vehicle for Lisbeth to do all that badass kicking-shit-out-of people, and it struck me very much as a male masturbatory fantasy in which he could give a woman a bunch of stereotypically "male" characteristics, and agenda for vengeance and call her "strong." I have been raped and I know many people who have been raped and I hate that this book is now propagating the myth that this is how a "strong" rape survivor reacts---by coldly plotting a revenge without ever betraying any of the true horror of her feelings. I can tell you I have never seen that happen, ever, with a rape. And it kills me that people read this damn book and now, more than ever, don't understand the mess that a person becomes after being raped. I can't wait to read a book about a truly strong rape survivor---someone who has the strength and courage to go through the grueling healing process. If the author had written about that---made Lisbeth a well-rounded woman who had access to her feelings, as well as someone who sought revenge---he would have come off as a compassionate person and not a narcissist. I am not saying a rape survivor shouldn't fight back---but I am saying that the version of "fighting back" that these books promote is completely one-dimensional, unrealistic, and not accessible to most of us. It left me feeling more misunderstood than ever and having to explain to people that people who don't react like Lisbeth to rape aren't "weak." I think this author had some serious issues.

December 17, 2011 2:35 PM
Athenia said...

Lisbeth has 3 or 4 tattoos. A wasp on her neck, the dragon on her back, and bracelet around her ankle I think. I believe she got a second one around her other ankle after she was raped.

December 17, 2011 9:23 PM
Rachel Stark said...

Thank Locke I'm not the only person who didn't find Lisbeth Salander to be even in the least bit empowering.

December 17, 2011 10:18 PM
Anonymous said...

Anonymous 2:35 P.M., thank you. Well-said.

I haven't read the books, because I think I just wouldn't like them. I only saw the one film (with my 80+ grandmother, and we had a good talk.) Can't remember which, because I just do not see torture and pain as entertainment. Few people seem to get that.

Anyway, I liked this post and I really appreciate some of the comments. First time visitor, must check out this blog....

December 18, 2011 9:29 AM
Anonymous said...

My father loved these books. I read the first one, found it creepy and offputting, and gave up. Lisbeth Salander felt too much like a male fantasy to me for reasons I couldn't quite articulate. This post puts a name on a lot of it.

December 18, 2011 11:22 AM
Anonymous said...

I think what bothers me most about all this, is giving ... rapists/angry/sexually confused/perverts something to watch in the theatre. Why can't it just be a 'and it happened' instead of making it so visual?

December 19, 2011 2:03 PM
Carmencita said...

I feel like you didn't read the books. First of all, Lisbeth doesn't fuck everybody and if she did, what of it?!!!! She has sexual relationships with people who aren't assholes, when she wants to. These people don't fit into a narrow 'type'. I think that's fairly realistic. Many people I'm willing and interested in having sex with aren't anything alike. She has lots of tattoos. Blomkvist doesn't save her and doesn't seem to see her as a fuck or a love interest. He seems to respect her intelligence and knows she can help him in the investigation (and knows she wants to; it's her curiosity that keeps her coming back to the case, not a desire for Blomkvist). She completely ignores him for big chunks of the books. She doesn't seem to seek a romance with him and he doesn't heal her. Mimi sees her for who she is as well. Mimi has a romantic relationship with her. Blomkvist has more of a friend and occasional lover relationship with her. Blomkvist seemed to attract a lot of women because he RESPECTS people and he was down to earth and usually not a jerk. He respected her wishes to back off. Lisbeth was not a perfectly-wrought character (and I'm not talking about human flaws). But she is not some weakling (physically, mentally or emotionally). Did you read the same books I did? I don't know where you got #1 from.

Also, according to the books she is not 'hot' as you put it. Not that it matters. People are attracted to other parts of her, not just her looks. Mimi, Blomkvist, others.

3. There's more than one definition of strong. If you mean physically, no, Salander is not muscle-strong. But she is frakking FAST and vicious, and timely with weapons. She can use force when in a physical fight, but her skill is with speed, precision, and inflicting a lot of damage in a few amount of strokes.

#5 is completely off base utterly. Give her a rose and she's yours?

#6 the poster for the American movie are stupid. They changed the title of the book too (and consequently the movie). From "Men who Hate Women" to "Girl with the Dragon Tattoo". Thus infantilizing Lisbeth as a 'girl' among other problems I have.

#7 The clothing store? Lisbeth doesn't care that much about clothing, she doesn't spend a lot of time styling/grooming herself, so I wouldn't put a lot of stock in where she shops as being indicative of her character

#8 Lisbeth Salander reminds me not at all of Lara Croft. She's plenty more antisocial, a lot more intelligent, introverted, and not conventionally sexy.

#9 She knew kindness. She had learned to cope with her shit life. She was organized, held down a job, didn't completely close herself off from everyone forever (though that would have been okay too, it just would have made for a different type of book. She had Mimi and her friends, she had her boss as an acquaintance, but not a friend. She had the one caregiver and legal guardian who actually gave a damn about her and didn't just read her file to get a bead on her personality. She has her hacker friends who just know her by her handle but share common interests.

Seriously, you are deliberately omitting a lot of pertinent information.

I'm not saying her character didn't suffer from some tropes, but she's not the woman you paint her to be here; at all.

December 19, 2011 8:30 PM
The Rejectionist said...

“...with the right make-up her face could have put her on any billboard in the world”; “She had no faith in herself”; “in spite of the tattoos and the pierced nose and eyebrows she was…well…attractive. It was inexplicable”; “She was convinced that her skinny body was repulsive…She did not have much to offer”; “Bjurman had chosen her as a victim. That told her something about the way she was viewed by other people”; “he had never been able to shake off the feeling that Lisbeth Salander was a perfect victim.”

December 19, 2011 11:25 PM
doctressjulia said...

AMAZING post. Found you via IBTP. I cannot bring myself to read or watch any of this shit. Thank you for articulating why that is so very well.

May I also NOT recommend anything by Neal Stephenson. He also enjoys having his 'strong female chars' raped by men. No woman 'gets raped' they are RAPED. BY MEN. NAME THE PERPS. Do not erase them.

Joanna Russ
CJ Cherryh
Sheri Tepper
James Tiptree
Octavia Butler

Feminist sci-fi FTW.

December 25, 2011 3:18 PM
Anonymous said...

Thank you so much for this. I mistakenly saw the American version of the movie on Christmas Eve with my entire family. That's the last time I'll see a movie without reading the book first. As a warning, the movie spends a lot of time Lisbeth getting raped and the scenes are very explicit. Like more than I thought was allowed for an R rating.

It was gross and disgusting and misogynistic and I'm still trying to wash my brain out.

December 25, 2011 3:39 PM
apgeeksout said...

@ Anonymous - Near as I can tell, the tipping point between an R and NC-17 rating is way less likely to be graphic violence - even sexualized violence - than it is consensual sex that a female character enjoys "too much".

Le R., thanks for this post and the one you did about the book at Tiger Beatdown. You've underlined all the reasons I have no desire to engage with this series, no matter how many times people tilt their heads at me and think if not say, "But you're always complaining about female characters... This one's tough. And you're still not satisfied?"

Also, I would read the hell and confetti out of "Is awesome, loves self, probably won't have sex with you".

December 27, 2011 11:26 AM
mandy muse said...

I just came back from a remote region of India where some trafficked women are not being well-served by the local NGO. More I cannot say publicly, but it sounds like maybe you might know someone who knows an NGO that might be interested in helping some women who only speak Hindi find out about their rights and file paperwork to get them? Holler if I should email you with more about this, and if you can't think of anyone, that's cool, too - I'm in the casting a wide net phase :)

December 28, 2011 3:42 PM
Post a Comment