Special Guest Post: Chérie l'Ecrivain on Teenage Blood Running in Our Veins
Tuesday, January 18, 2011
Chérie turned thirty a few months ago. I celebrated with great enthusiasm, which means I got drunk for four days and purchased everything I set my eyes on that I wanted. Over 96 hours this included an enormous amount of cheese and whiskey, two pairs of vintage gloves, several hundred dollars of imported lingerie and an electric guitar. It was pretty awesome. As I preened over these items in my abode, I congratulated myself on reaching adulthood at last. This, I thought, is really not so bad. Then last week I was perusing the menu of my local diner, trying to convince myself that jalapeno poppers, a grilled cheese sandwich, and a bottle of Kolsch do not a healthy dinner make, when I realized I could not remember the last time I had actually eaten a vegetable, and I was terrified. What idiot, I wondered, put me in charge. I more or less run my life like I’m still a fifteen year old girl, and I’m not entirely sure how I manage to keep myself alive (I suspect Le R plays a large role in ensuring that I continue to function).
I have it on good authority that I’m not the only woman my age to still feel a strong connection to the outsized emotions, identity issues and uncontrollable impulses so commonly associated with adolescent girls, which is why I’m consistently stunned by how rarely their stories make it onto bookstore shelves beyond the YA section. Teenage boys are well represented in this arena, and whether we’re talking about recent additions--Skippy Dies, Lowboy--or classics--Catcher in the Rye, Rule of the Bone--it’s clear that the story of the male adolescent has its place in the canon. Teenage girls, on the other hand, are for the most part relegated to the YA section. The intimation, of course, is that there are aspects of the teenage boy experience that can resonate with everyone, but the stories of teenage girls will be of interest only to other teenage girls.
There are exceptions, but a great number of these are memoirs or novels that serve as cautionary tales, where the protagonist suffers from some ailment that can range from promiscuity to a drinking problem to cutting to an eating disorder. In terms of the narrative, however, they serve the same purpose: the all-consuming, about-to-explode feelings of that time in a girl’s life blown up so large they threaten her existence and need to be reined in before they literally kill her. I am weirdly fascinated by these books, and individually each one reads like a healthy catharsis for the author or an honest portrayal of a fucked-up kid. When you look at the whole genre lined up on a shelf, though, the message seems to be clear: anyone who manages to negotiate her own girlhood without ending up in a hospital has somehow dodged a bullet.
Being a teenage girl is not all about your fucked-up relationship with food or losing your virginity to the wrong boy. The strange and romantic world of female friendships, falling in love with science or art or music, the slow discovery of the things you’ll be passionate about for your whole life--these are the stories that are woefully absent from those shelves. I remember the first time I heard the Pixies, and Hüsker Dü, and Team Dresch, and the world split open and revealed itself to me. The first rock shows I ever went to--I think I still have the ticket stubs somewhere, that’s how momentous those occasions were. Or the first time I saw a Hal Hartley movie (Amateur, it was playing at MOMA, a glorious 35mm print) and I felt like suddenly I understood what a movie was, and what a movie could do. I spent my adolescence making things, zines and t-shirts and mix tapes and paintings, I was constantly covered in glitter and glue, always writing in my journal or sending someone a letter. And the terrible understanding that eventually I was going to be in charge of the whole operation--nutrition, bank accounts, my temper, my clothes. All of that is still imprinted on me somewhere--some of it is still happening--and it’s as important as any of the heartbreak and self-loathing and insecurity considered so typical of those years. And it would be nice if literature could recognize that the first two-thirds of my life were as valid an experience as, say, Holden Caulfield’s.
It’s easy for me to understand that guys of all ages can still read and relate to the stories of their adolescent counterparts. The majority of my friends could be classified as thirty year old boys, and the cultural joke that men never really grow up (witness every comedy movie made, like, ever) has been worn extremely thin by now (thanks Judd Apatow!). Maybe admitting that there isn’t a whole lot separating grown women from their adolescent selves either is just too frightening, since it appears that we’re the ones who are supposed to manage not just our own impulses but the impulses of an entire gender that has given itself permission to remain permanently immature. How are we supposed to push the guys to grow up if we come clean about having never really done it ourselves? Well, tough shit, I don’t see why they should get to have all the extended post-adolescence fun. Why do you think I just bought myself an electric guitar?
Bravo from another thirty-year-old woman who doesn't feel ready for adulthood.
Hi Cherie, great post! I know most people our age have the sort of gleeful/terrified feeling of being the inmates in charge of the asylum in the adult world. But I feel like there a few classics that have girls on the verge of womanhood learning lessons that I return to a lot:
Jane Eyre and Emma. Jane Eyre and her cousin St. John ponder a lot about the pleasures and pains of restraint and seeing that choosing one path often has to exclude another.
Emma just teaches us to be nice to each other when we have power, even if it's only the power of being popular. A useful fucking lesson at any time of life, I think.
But yeah, I could sure use some contemporary authors laying down thoughts like this.
I LIKE THIS
i have been thinking about somewhat similar things also lately, or maybe just feeling old / panicking about the rapid adultification of my life (lease?! 9-to-5 job?! am i boring now?!) or being nostalgic or something I DON'T KNOW something about feeling like i ought to feel disconnected/ashamed of my teenagehood at this point but like i really don't and i DON'T UNDERSTAND and this was like all that stuff except said smart instead of like a babbling overemotional 16 year old girl like i just did here O YES
HAL HARTLEY! Yes, god yes. My first was Surviving Desire. And Henry Fool! And the dance scene from Simple Men...
And yes, I too wonder why is a coming-of-age story for a young man usually considered LITERATURE whereas a coming-of-age story for a young woman is "chick lit." I'd be more angry, but I have to take my daughter to her kung fu class now.
"...an entire gender that has given itself permission to remain permanently immature." I love this sentance. I'm trying to do my part for girl/womankind by raising an aware boy/man. I'm not sure how well I'm doing since my 10 year-old daughter can do our taxes but my 13 year-old son struggles with making grilled cheese sandwiches. At least his favorite author is Sherman Alexie.
Some days it just feels downright taboo to admit how much you enjoyed your awesome, horrifying, thrilling emotional (AND physical) roller-coaster that is girlhood. I mean, it did make us who we are today, didn't it? It's about time somebody starts taking it back one electric guitar at a time.
awesome, awesome post.
I loved this: "I spent my adolescence making things, zines and t-shirts and mix tapes and paintings, I was constantly covered in glitter and glue, always writing in my journal or sending someone a letter..." that's how I spent my teen years as well, and how I plan on spending the rest of my twenties, haha.
Thanks for the great post and the eye-opening.
I sort of think that boyhood is canonized and literary because the club that made the canon was full of men for, like, ever. And now that there are woman literary taste-makers the pattern has already been established and ingrained to the point that even women reading girlhood stories feel like they're chick lit.
And I also think it has something to do with the fact that women are readers. To make a sweeping generalization, women tend to read far more than men and are willing to stretch themselves out of the genres with which they feel comfortable. Men, perhaps because they are "given...permission to remain permanently immature," aren't as flexible and open-minded. My husband has a habit of only reading books with male protags, but after months of begging him to read The Hunger Games--he finally did and he loved it! Even though it was about a teen girl.
Women have no problem reading about men. It just takes a lot more to get men to read about women--whatever that says about men in general.
How did I miss this yesterday? How? This is not a rhetorical question. Someone please explain.
Okay, this is awesome.
And when is Cherie's novel that will correct all this going to be finished? Yes? YES?
Fab. And so right on, as are the comments. I write YA, and this is a question I haven't pondered. Maybe a grown-up novel is in order.
I'm a male writer, currently writing a novel with a teen girl protagonist, which isn't specifically YA-oriented. It'll probably be crap, but hey, I tried.
Anyway, thought this post was pretty awesome. Made me think.
In an envelope in a drawer in my house is an eight year old printout of exactly this kind of novel that I've kept not working on because I couldn't imagine anyone would ever care for such a topic. But maybe it's time to dig it up again.
Post a Comment