Today's Recommended Reading
Saturday, June 5, 2010
Here is a very interesting post over at Racialicious by the very brilliant Thea Lim, on how to read and respond to literature of color. She concludes with this (YES EXACTLY THANK YOU, says the Rejectionist, who is getting a little tired of (white) industry professionals exhorting would-be writers to refrain from having opinions that are 'political'):
The bottom line for me, is to just be conscious of the fact that you’re white. And that white writers are white. And that all writers that write about humans are writing ethnic concerns. And I think it’s very important for writers and teachers of writing to be able to fess up to that: all writing is racial, all writing is political. All choices on a reading list are political.
Also reproduced therein is this quote from Junot Díaz OMG CAN WE HAVE A DAY WHERE WE ALL JUST TALK ABOUT HOW AMAZING JUNOT DIAZ IS:
We’re in a country where white is considered normative; it’s a country where white writers are simply writers, and writers of Latino descent are Latino writers. This is an issue whose roots are deeper than just the publishing community or how an artist wants to self-designate. It’s about the way the U.S. wants to view itself and how it engineers otherness in people of color and, by doing so, props up white privilege. I try to battle the forces that seek to “other” people of color and promote white supremacy. But I also have no interest in being a “writer,” either, shorn from all my connections and communities. I’m a Dominican writer, a writer of African descent, and whether or not anyone else wants to admit it, I know also that Stephen King and Jonathan Franzen are white writers. The problem isn’t in labeling writers by their color or their ethnic group; the problem is that one group organizes things so that everyone else gets these labels but not it. No, not it. -- Interview with Slate, 2008
wow.
is all I say.
Well, I also say Thea Lim is fearless and so are you. And I thank you for it.
There's another side to that. Junot Diaz can call me a white writer, but if I called myself a white writer? Good lord, the fallout would be intense. It wouldn't be some kind of gesture of parity. I wouldn't be acknowledging the implicit segregation of how we categorize one another. I'd be exerting some kind of overt claim to white power.
You may think that's silly, but I've seen it, and no amount of explanation ever wipes away that first assumption.
(Incidentally, if you're a fan of Sealab 2021, the "Black Debbie" episode is a great compliment to this post.)
As a white Yankee writer whose novel is set in the South, is told in first person, and features characters of color, I am PAINFULLY aware of my whiteness.
But not as painfully aware of my whiteness as many of my beta readers, most of whom are professors. (I live in a college town.) I've had more than one suggest I never describe my characters of color as characters of color. They felt it inappropriate that I, or rather, my mc, label them as such. Instead, they suggest, my mc should describe the color of their skin and let the reader guess for themselves what that means. I personally can't imagine anything more condescending or less honest than pretending my 15 yo white mc who lives in the South does not see race. She does. We all do.
My personal view is that what I owe the world as a writer, and, let's be honest, a pretty mediocre writer at best - I am no Junot Diaz, never will be, and don't want to be (I just want to be me! like the Far Side penguin) - anyway, what I owe the world as a writer is my honesty. There's really nothing else or better that I have to offer.
As note, honesty isn't the right word.
Honest best, while a stupid sounding phrase, is closer to what I meant.
I think Junot Diaz has it right...we can no more avoid writing race/politics etc. into our work than we can avoid feeling them.
What is rather interesting is that the culture of "otherness" immediately causes writers designated as "other" to dispute/celebrate/display their "otherness" in the only way they know how, by writing. Sort of an opposite and equal reaction thing...
Thanks for the recommendations maam.
i love junot diaz, and i am so glad you keep bringing up ethnic issues in literature. thanks.
kate
www.transatlanticsketches.com
labels confine more than they define
Funny you should mention Junot Diaz because I'm reading him now, and let me tell you, I have never been so aware that I am a white girl from the deep South than when reading his book. I don't get so many of the references in the book (not to mention I took French instead of Spanish in school). Luckily for me, DH grew up in that swath of NJ that is the book's setting and spent lots of time in the home of one of his Dominican friends, so he can translate for me. Also good for me is that I speak fluent Nerd, so there's that.
Post a Comment