Love is Like a Bottle of Query
Thursday, April 1, 2010
We know some of you think we are making up the terribleness of many of the queries we receive, and we are in fact a hateful and high-fullutent person, lolling about with our dogeared copy of Swann's Way (en français, naturellement!) and looking down our nose at the toiling masses whilst extolling leftist-elitist tripe! Well, that last part is true (okay, not in French. The Lydia Davis translation)! BUT THE QUERIES ARE STILL TERRIBLE. And, after racking our little brain for a comparable experience we could force you to undergo, so as to truly have some understanding of what our working life is like, we realized: reading queries is a lot like reading online personal ads. Like, A LOT. So try this little thought-experiment: go to, say, Craigslist New York. Scroll through the "men seeking women" section (IT'S FOR RESEARCH). Now imagine ALL OF THOSE PEOPLE ARE WRITING NOVELS. Seriously, all of those people ARE probably writing novels, which is fine, and we are happy for them, but DO YOU WANT TO READ THEIR QUERIES? No, you do not. To fully illustrate our point, we present to you a number of examples, selected from real live online profiles from a variety of dating websites. THE THINGS WE DO FOR YOU PEOPLE.
NOTE: We tried really, really hard to be gender- and orientation-neutral in our selection, but the particularly insane profiles were all heterosexual men ("Obviously," says our Support Team). Make of that what you will.
1. The Hostile Query. "Am I that repulsive or am I cursed? being nocturnal has its disadvantages but this is ridiculous! I've been on this site for over a year and the only contacts I've gotten is 2 scam messages!" Would you go on a date with this person? No. So why would you note that your query has been rejected 234 times? Or tell us how much you hate agents? Or let us know that publishing is a sinking ship helmed by effete commies? Hmm? You see where we are going with this?
2. The Snoozefest Query. "I am a very caring and compassionate person. I enjoy reading, writing, traveling, music, good food and quality conversation." OH SORRY WHAT WAS THAT WE FELL ASLEEP. In all likelihood, is this a very nice person, who would doubtless be a very charming date? Yes. Are you ever going to find out? No. This is like saying, "My book is thoughtful and well-written," or "I have spent many years learning the craft of writing." TELL US SOMETHING WE DON'T ALREADY KNOW, PEOPLE!
3. The Query Letter Written From the POV of Your Novel's Protagonist. "Hulk have needs! Hulk have feelings! Hulk wonder if love exists or if love just a delusion Hulk driven to embrace rather than suffer the utter loneliness of life! Hulk not like other guys, Hulk sensitive, warm, nurturing and protective. Anybody fuck with Hulk's woman and Hulk smash them like bug!" You see now why that doesn't work?
4. The WTF Query. "im looking for awomen for ltr relatioship,im single independent person looking for a nice women.im looking for areal women any race,any religion any cast.important good humanbeing,imalso amatured well established person,im very caring loyal person &i also need a loyal&honest women.im not say im a beautifull person,but i have a charming personality im good looking&handsum guy" You think we are exaggerating when we say we have received queries that read exactly like this. We are not.
5. The Asshat Query. "Some notes on how I search the women on this site: 1. I look at pictures. If there are none that show the person, I move on. 2. If they look good, I look at: Height, age, smokes and drinks. Answers of 5'3-5'8, 18-25, no (etc) and yes (etc), in that order, earn a favorite. 3. I then read the article. Ones I am interested in I will try to find using sleuthing skills." Yeah. Kind of like those queries from the next Nabokov, "Hemmingway," and/or Melville, whose work will shortly be adapted by Spielberg for the big screen. Don't call us; we'll call you, tiger.
6. THE WINNER: "I'm a good, game lass with a big ticker and an even bigger bullshit detector. I like to ride that fine line that is so right, between the fucked-up avant-garde and the really low-brow un-mentionables of life. I'm a word nerd with a penchant for philosophy. I like tricksters, that Joseph Campbell concept of folks or creatures that stir things up purely for the purpose of unveiling the truth and causing a little mischief, and I like to believe I have a bit of this in me. My bark is as bad as my bite, but if I care for you, you are forever golden in my eyes and I will treat you like the heavenly creature that you are. I am fearless when it comes to love and life, and I don't take kindly to those who aren't of the same mind set." Once you've winnowed out the nutballs, dating, like requesting fulls, is a subjective business. Maybe you hate Joseph Campbell with an abiding passion, and would instantly rule out this young lady, regardless of how nice she sounded otherwise. Maybe an agent only reps spy novels, and will ruthlessly send your ms to the shredder even if you actually ARE the next Nabokov. Whatever. This paragraph tells us so much about this person, her interests, what makes her tick; it is lively; it is compelling; it contains charm. Think of your query like this: you are selling us not only your fabulous gem of a book, but that package of delights that is YOU. What stands out is not hyperbole, weird gimmicks, or unwanted gifts; what stands out is a hefty dose of wit and a voice that is utterly yours.
Thanks to number 4, I need to go get my inhaler.
That is all.
Seriously, these are not made up? SERIOUSLY?!? This little comparison just made me feel pity for literary agents and as someone sitting on a lot of rejections I thought that would be impossible to do. Mission accomplished Le R
What if you're not witty?
Great, now I'm going to have to become an accountant.
Yes. YES! And everyone who liked this should immediately go read Kit Whitfield's "PUBLISHER-DATING DICTIONARY". Some examples:
You say: 'I know you don't usually accept unsolicited manuscripts, but please, just have a look at this.'
Dating equivalent: 'I know you're married, but please, just go out with me once.'
You say: 'I know you don't usually publish this kind of thing, but please, just have a look at this.'
Dating equivalent: 'I know you're gay, but please, just go out with me once.'
In fact, I'm going to just link to Le R. & Kit on my blog today...
The INTERN has just flagged up a site that could give us solitary types a taste of slush:
http://internspills.blogspot.com/2010/03/even-you-can-surf-slush.html
Dear Matt, well, you better be good then. Hee hee.
OMG CKHB THAT IS AMAZING!!!
LYDIA IS ALIVE!
Haha. My apologies, dear Le R, I've been WRITING. A lot. ;)
And I agree. CKHB, that IS amazing. Thanks for the link!
Dang, this *is* a subjective business. I'd flee the Big Ticker lady nearly as fast as I'd run from stalker guy-- er, sorry, sleuthing skills guy.
Genius!!!
Awesome idea comparing personal ads with queries. Makes a point and makes me laugh (or cringe in horror). Thanks!
Dear alaskaravenclaw, we read through TWENTY-FIVE PAGES OF ONLINE DATING PROFILES before we found someone we would even consider BEING IN THE SAME ROOM WITH, cut us some slack!
The Asshat query..
*Makes note to send one of these out of sheer irony*
i'd totally call the hulk.
We thought for a moment that you could parler the francais and we loved you even more.
We still love you anyhow :)
Anybody who reads your site and still writes a query like this deserves to be forced on a date with one of these people!
How about the online dating version of the "non-query"?
"I'm saving us both some time since I'm awesome and I'm sure you're sick of reading these things by now. So, yeah. I'll be at the coffee shop on Fourteenth on Friday at 2. Just meet me there."
WVS: ejudger. Not making that up.
Be honest. That fourth one was you, wasn't it? ;)
Holy smokes. Am I really the only one ballsy enough to go out with ALL of them? OR am I the only person trying intentionally to get herself into a justifiable-homicide type situation? (I put that question in my query.)
I have to admit - I'd be tempted to call the hulk as well.
uhhhhh.
SO YOU LOOK IN THE ONLINE PERSONAL ADS BUT YOU REJECT MY LOVE?!?!
(am i too needy??)
also: these people are in desperate need of Query-YES!
no?
Lydia Davis has a translation of Swann's Way? You mean the Lydia Davis of The Collected Stories of Lydia Davis fame? How did I not know this?
Do you think my hardcover set of The Remembrance of Things Past would be upset if I traded him in for a nice trade-paperback set of the Lydia Davis? What sort of alimony do you think I'd have to pay?
They only got Lydia Davis for the first volume; the rest are all different people. But yes, the same Lydia Davis, and yes, it is amazing (we COULD read it in French, Claire Dawn, but we are LAAAAZY. Our French is more at the Dumas level).
oh those scream 'loser' and 'pathetic'!
I sure hope my queries don't sound like that!
Me like Hulk. Ok, not really.
I am pretty sure Number 4 sent me an email needing my help to get money out of an account in Nigeria.
Have you seen this?
http://i.imgur.com/HL1ZR.jpg
I swear I'm not trying to infect your computer with porn, viruses, or other evil web-beasties. A friend linked this to me, and I immediately thought of Le R.
Great minds, CKHB! I'd read that a while back and was laughing thinking of it :D. Love. It.
Rejectionist, this made my day! Also, now I've decided your job probably goes from fun, to morbidly amusing, to horrifying in the space of a few queries. Now we know why all assistants love their whiskies.
Thanks for this!
I definitely have that same copy of Swann's Way. Lydia Davis came to my college and read some of her short stories, which were unbelievably awesome. She was kind of rude when signing books BUT WHO CARES I LOVE LYDIA DAVIS ANYWAYS (and you can't expect touring authors to be polite all the time...though it would be nice)
Don't feel bad, Le R. MY French is only at the Saint-Exupéry level.
Oh, and I can sing about half the French national anthem. But I have a *really* good accent. ;)
Awesome post!
Uncanny.
Lady Hulk find her long lost love! No more smash people skulls.
Excellent.
OMG NUMBER FOUR *claws at eyes*
I worked at an extremely small press attached to a non-profit; we didn't get a lot of slush. Now I see what I've been missing. Well, since they had to let me go due to the economy and I'm freelancing, maybe I will find my very own slush pile somewhere!
Delightful! I might not read many of their queries, but I would buy a book of personal ads given this same treatment.
I volunteer at a small publishing house as a reader and yes, no exaggeration. Number 4's are real. (Can't believe it? Neither could I.)
I dunno...I'd like to get paid to read these all day. LOL
Oh, wait. If you're reading these all day, you're probably not publishing anything, so probably not making much mone--
okey-dokey. Got it. Pretty entertaining, though.
The little bleetz says: Sounds more like you're looking for someone who talks like any other new yorker - like as if they're the only ones who can make it in the world (and as if that voice can't be faked anyway).....
AND BEFORE YOU WRITE ME OFF AS A CRANK(Y)LITTLE BLEETZTER...
Nice boring people are the ones forking out their doe to watch/read other boring people, like the SLEEPLESS IN SEATLE'S and BRIGITTE JONESes... And as I recall, Hulk had his own TV series and a coupla movies....
And lets not forget the poor asshats... they fill every shelf in every literary section of every library in the world - and probably a few offworld.
Instead of judging books by their cover stories - perhaps the best agents are those who become adept at spotting the gemstone inside the rubble... or in this case, the rabble? ;)
A total laugh trip. Every one of them sounds like some to the essays I read at work. Shakes head.
True story -- Lydia Davis was my beginning fiction professor in college. She was awesome!
Aren't you forgetting the screamer query? Usually written by octagenarians or their computer-literate equivalents:
I AM LIKE WANT REAL WOMEN AND NOT WOMEN WHO IS NOT READY FOR REAL MAN WITH REAL NEEDS AND EVERYTHING TO PLEAZE AM WANT KISS AND I INVIATE YOU MY HOUSE FOR REAL MEN TO WOMEN TIME.
Query:
MY NOVEL IS BESTEREST AND IS LIKE TWILIGHT II TEH SEQUEL AND GONE WITH TEH BREEZE AND NEED REAL AGENT WITH REAL NEEDZ. IF MY BOOK WAS PERSON IT WOULD BE JOHN WAYNE.
Perspicasious.
Why are you anonymous? Do you accept anonymous queries? Wondering.
Well hey, at least my query isn't that bad.
Great read!
Haha, John C's comment. Hilarious. Besterest. Haha.
Post a Comment