More Homework for White Folks
Wednesday, March 31, 2010
After that whole brouhaha over the Magic Under Glass cover, we stayed away from internet conversations about racism in publishing for a while. Honestly, they seem more often than not to go like this:
PERSON OF COLOR: posts thoughtful, amazing, carefully-considered, and very insightful commentary about racism/appropriation/marginalization/being a good ally
MANY, MANY WHITE PEOPLE: leave totally horrifying comments (see "but I'm a good person so I can't possibly be who you meant," "whtevr get over it u ppl r so sensitive," "we are post-racial now," "one time someone called my Irish grandfather a bad name which is exactly the same as your experience of racism and look at me I'm fine," etc.)
and then we put out our own eye with a fork and are of no use to the People's Revolution. But anyway! All of that was just to say we missed some of these posts when they first went up, but they are all amazing, and EVERYONE NEEDS TO GO READ THEM RIGHT NOW. Okay! Thanks.
The Book Smugglers compiled the most considered and comprehensive overview of whitewashing in publishing ever, and finished it off with another out-of-the-ballpark letter from Ari, who is seriously our hero, and some days when we are feeling really un-optimistic about the future of the People's Revolution, we think about Ari, and then we feel better.
Also our hero: Neesha Meminger, who routinely posts some of the most thoughtful and compelling writing about race (and cookies) in the universe, has a great post about representation. OH LOOK NEESHA INTERVIEWED OLUGBEMISOLA RHUDAY-PERKOVICH AND THEY BOTH SAID A BUNCH OF CRAZY SMART THINGS HOW EXCITING. This made us cry: "I hope that readers know that I am writing to them from that place in myself that is both broken-hearted and beautiful to that same place in them; that I'm hoping that we meet and are transformed in some way together. That we're all imperfect, self-conscious, want more, don't even know what the questions are sometimes, much less the answers...and we can all get beyond ourselves, even in very small ways, to make a difference in this world." Olugbemisola Rhuday-Perkovich, if you get any more awesome, our head is going to fall off.
Here is a very fabulous post from the very fabulous Zetta Elliott on her experience at the NYC Teen Author Festival (Dear Zetta: "Should I, as a woman of color, expect my “white sisters” to rush to my side and stand in solidarity on this issue that doesn’t negatively affect them?" We know you are being wry and resigned but YES YOU SHOULD WE LIKE TO AIM HIGH OVER HERE AT THE PEOPLE'S REVOLUTION. LADIES LET'S STEP UP OKAY? OKAY!). You should also read her Huffpo post about self-publishing. You should also read some Sarah Schulman while you're at it.
Finally, here is an interesting series of posts on the maybe-almost-but-not-quite-yay-they-fixed-it-anyway whitewashing of the cover for Holly Black's forthcoming White Cat, from Book Smugglers and Gal Novelty, and Holly's response (Dear Simon and Schuster: if someone wanted to send us a galley for this book so we could not have to wait until it comes out to read it because it is totally going to be so awesome confirm your success in non-whitewashing we would not say no).
Wow, I love this post! And I totally agree. Most of the characters in my novel are brown, so it would be pretty obvious if there was any whitewashing involves. Plus, my protag is sort of thick, so they'd better not stick a skinny girl on the cover!
Okay, I'm loath to send you this link, because it might send you over the edge ("We can’t sell this as a romantic comedy because the main character is Asian. You have to go sell it as an Asian-American film. Good luck.") but I *am* telling you about it because the movie is showing in NYC right now and you should go see it.
Thank you! I have some reading to do.
Have a post up myself to talk about the unwritten character rules like how it is not okay for a Black character to like watermelon.
Would love to hear from you and your followers about this if you're so inclined.
Brilliant post, Le R. Thanks for all the links.
I can just do the head-nod, yes? *head-nod*
I study disparities in my day job, so in spite of my whiteness, institutional racism is a topic close to my heart. I appreciate you keeping us all informed and every time you share these links, I pass them on to anyone I can reach. Keep fighting the good fight.
-a white sister fighting on the same team.
YES.
When CKHB tweeted about the "no romantic comedies for Asian-Americans" thing last night, I first thought it had to be a joke. Then felt a little sick. Racism is alive and well--and growing--in the US. It's even encouraged by a major political party. In California, a candidate for governor has only one plank in his platform: racism.
Every one of us who wants to live in a civilized society has to speak out against this creepy, idiotic return to the bad old days.
Sarah, I'm off to check out your post.
Le R: I've not read many of the "Oh, yeah, but my grandfather was an immigrant whatever so I get it" comments but there is NO WAY that even the most thickheaded person cannot see the inherent wrongness in portraying a PoC main character as lily white on the cover of the book. It's an indefensible practice and frankly annoying as a reader.
It bugs me if the race and hair color are right and nothing else seems to match. "Voluptuous" MCs with heavy curves who look like stick figures on the cover, tat bearing midriff exposed goth chicks featured in front of a story where not one tattoo is mentioned, etc. So, yeah, I'm gonna notice if the Asian protag has light brown hair on the cover.
Rigid prejudice is just stupid, whatever form it takes.
@ CKHB: Holy hell. I just checked out your link and that is...wow. Just wow. I guess Asian people can't be funny? Or is it that they can't be romantic? Or just not both at the same time? WHAT?
This is great. The more people know and are outraged by whitewashing of covers, the more things can be done about it!
I may be way behind the times with this notation, but I just finished reading THE MYSTERIOUS BENEDICT SOCIETY (fantastic book), and Sticky, one of the heroes, has brown skin--yet is portrayed as a white boy on the cover. WHAT?!
Thanks for the post and the links. Zetta Elliott's post on the NYC Teen Author Festival and her HuffPo piece on self-publishing highlight the fact that many of the important books about and by PoC are not published by the major publishing houses but by small presses committed to diversity. And you won't find whitewashed covers from places like Just Us Books, for example.
That "Asian-American lead = Asian-American audience" is making me D: because last week I started my YA paranormal romance novel (which will have 100x the female ass-kicking as Twilight and its spawn, I guarantee you), and my lead is Asian-American. I'm a total WASP, but so many of my friends, past and present, have been Asians. The idea that I and others of my race "can't relate" to Asian-Americans is just so anathema to me, it goes beyond bullshit.
This is the rare kind of homework that I actually like and agree with.
@CKHB-I just commented at the Asian American lead so it must be a Asian American film post. *scoffs* That's so ridiculous. So then the Backup Plan should be promoted as Latino/a Film since j.Lo is the lead. *rolls eyes*
These are all great links. I love all these author's posts, Neesha always manages to express what I want to say far more eloquently than I ever could. And Zetta keeps me up to date on everything that is going on (not always in publishing either). Olugbemisola Rhuday Perkovich is going to go FAR! She's so sweet, amazing and deep. I love her, Reggie, Ruthie and all of 8th Grade Superzero.
And THANKYOU Le R for demanding that we hold white people accountable (i.e. telling Zetta that white authors should be in solidarity with her) more often than not, I think we bloggers of color tend to not expect much from our fellow non-POC bloggers, but you show us that we should demand better, more outrage and action aganist things that are just oh so wrong about publishing in general, and how POC are treated especially.
:o Thank you so much for the shoutout!
oh, le r., i could just hug you every day! thank you so much. and a big YES to neesha's post on representation -- please, everyone read it. this one too, on 'hood passes and home invasions', is amazing:
http://neeshameminger.blogspot.com/2010/03/hood-passes-home-invasions.html
Greetings! Your post gave me a big morale boost yesterday, and the timing couldn't have been better since I meet with the NYPL today...I don't know how to get people NOT to act out of self-interest, but it's reassuring to know we DO have allies in the blogosphere! Thanks...
Okay, the romantic comedy post made me throw up in my mouth a little :(.
Thanks for these links, Le R! Like Editorial Ass, I'm white, but trying to get over it ;).
Thanks to le r and CKHB for the links. I've been slowly reading them over the last few days. For any one who wonders why my characters are multi-culti, this is the reason. Perceptions must be changed and art always leads the way.
And, le r, you're totally right. Ari, Olugbemisola, and Neesha are amazing. We need you ladies and I thank you!
Post a Comment