sometimes nothing can be a real cool hand
About

It is only the second day of our Protest Action and already we are feeling anxious. Like, there are only five days in a work week! which means only FIVE BOOKS! which is WAY TOO FEW! and makes us feel like we felt on every single one of the SIXTEEN interviews we went on before securing our current illustrious position, where whatever harried HR person who was trying to assess our sanity/competence/ability to memorize exactly the preferred ratio of sugar-free vanilla syrup to espresso in potential boss's Corporate Coffee beverage of choice would ask us what our favorite book was and, even though we totally knew it was coming every time, we would feel like crying, because IF YOU CARE AT ALL ABOUT BOOKS YOU SHOULD FUCKING KNOW THERE IS NO ANSWER TO THAT WRETCHED WRETCHED QUESTION. We've been reading somewhere between two and three hundred books a year for the last, oh, say, at least two decades, which is a LOT of books to pick from, Author-friends, and we thought this little book-review project would be a lark but now it is making us want to weep with despair. Just so you know.

ALSO MAY WE PLEASE REMIND YOU NOT TO WRITE YOUR NOVEL IN "AN IMPRESSIONISTIC STYLE" PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE DO YOU HATE US? IS THAT IT? YOU HATE US, DON'T YOU.

Today's theme song: Tom Waits, "I Don't Wanna Grow Up"

No. 2: Donna Tartt, The Secret History

The Secret History was also a book we read at a very impressionable age, when we were enormously eager to depart the, shall we euphemistically say, intellectually cramped environs of our home turf and embark on our voyage to the storied realm of higher education, where of course everyone would be as elegant and brilliant as Henry and his friends, and we too would sit around fixing ourselves endless cocktails and translating Dante into Sanskrit out of sheer fabulous ennui. We have read this book so many times we sometimes forget it's fiction, and have on more than one occasion asked our Support Team if he remembers the time Judy Poovey gave Richard Demerol at that terrible party, only to remember mid-sentence that we are talking about imaginary people. The Secret History is that rarest and most perfect of things: a potboiler-hearted literary novel, a piece of literature that is, in essence, pure shameless crack, but so beautifully composed one does not feel the slightest bit of embarrassment at losing oneself altogether in its pages, half-expecting to hear Bunny's booming, honking voice at the window, shouting up a demand to be let in. Donna Tartt is a magnificently erudite writer, and an absolute master at creating that particular restless lovely nostalgia for a time that never existed and events that never took place; a gorgeous ache worthy of Fitzgerald, for a decadent world that is, despite its rotten core, immensely appealing. And, like Gatsby 's Nick, Richard Papen is an irredeemably unreliable narrator who wins you over even as you tell yourself you know better; so that you, like him, are so taken in by the trappings of wealth and brilliance that murdering two people comes to seem a regrettable but necessary inconvenience, and the ensuing inevitable fallout manages to impress itself upon you as tragedy rather than deserved retribution.

Valerie Geary said...

Delightful. Recently read and loved this book. Your review is spot on!

October 13, 2009 12:21 PM
CKHB said...

Thank you for reminding me how much I loved this book. Off to add it to my LibraryThing list!

October 13, 2009 12:30 PM
Marsha Sigman said...

Good Lord, I sit here mesmerized by one of the best reviews I have read in a long time. You're pretty good.
Have you been drinking?

I want to read that book.

October 13, 2009 12:32 PM
The Rejectionist said...

Hee hee, Marsha. Not at work. Not yet. Oh wait! It's almost one! In that case, yes.

October 13, 2009 12:50 PM
Ink said...

Ooh, I liked that book. Though, I must admit, I liked The Little Friend better. Is that sacrilege? Or just like preferring the understudy to the headliner?

October 13, 2009 1:02 PM
Caroline Starr Rose said...

Read The Secret History this summer and was jealous (Tratt was an undergrad when she wrote this???)and hooked. I think we've all known a Judy Poovey or two.

The Neverending Story. The Secret History. Cool. I'm two for two.

October 13, 2009 1:30 PM
Jacqui said...

Absolutely love this book and have read a good number of "In the mode of The Secret History" crap novels in a desperate attempt to find another as worthy.

October 13, 2009 1:41 PM
Eimear said...

I think The Secret History is the novel most writers wish they'd written. So delicious and gossipy but literary too. Notes On A Scandal inspired similar feelings in me (although you don't really want to actually meet the characters the way you do with The Secret History). Oh, Francis. He's my fave.

October 13, 2009 2:53 PM
myimaginaryblog said...

For a while my daughter always wanted to know what my favorite color was, and since the question always caused me anxiety, we worked out a deal where I could choose two or three at a time and vary them every day (and even come up with exciting combinations--ooooh!) (You read hundreds of books; I like colors. It was an obvious comparison.)

Maybe you should start a book-reviewing blog? Become a professional reviewer?

(And I will keep liking colors.)

October 13, 2009 3:05 PM
Dana said...

Oh! I love Donna Tartt. Both The Secret History and The Little Friend. I just love you more and more every day Rejectionist. :)

October 13, 2009 3:30 PM
Lisa Katzenberger said...

Oh, this is one of my favorite books. Perfect review.

October 13, 2009 3:36 PM
The Rejectionist said...

Hmm, perhaps we should take a poll? Anyone else besides Ink prefer The Little Friend? Our Support Team is also in this corner. We didn't love it so much, but we that might be because we secretly wanted it to be The Secret History: Bunny Rises Again or something, which is not so fair to Ms. Tartt.

OMG, also, TSH knockoffs make us SO DISPLEASED. Anyone read The Likeness? Which is such a straight rip of TSH we were surprised Tana French didn't get sued? FRRGH. (Like ARRGH but grumpier.) Into the Woods was pretty promising, too; too bad she had to RUIN IT by PLAGIARIZING her second novel.

My, aren't we loquacious today.

October 13, 2009 3:40 PM
Marsha Sigman said...

I knew it! That long of a post and you only said 'fucking' once? Plus you were waxing poetic there at the end.

Enough joking. It was a beautifully written review. It is not something I would normally pick up to read and I find myself almost desperate to do so.

And I'm not just saying that because now I have been drinking too.

October 13, 2009 3:53 PM
Amber Tidd Murphy said...

I've never read Tartt. Now I'm gonna!

October 13, 2009 6:26 PM
Editorial Anonymous said...

Those HR people know that. It's a trick question.
The correct response is: "Oh, how to choose? I love A for its Aquality, and B for its Bquality, and C for the way it etc etc etc, and did you read the new Q? Of course it's maybe not quite as good as that author's P, but it's terrific for readers who love S. Oh! And I forgot about T! Brilliant! And if you like books in that vein, you should really try U, V, W, and X. What do you mean the interview's over? Wait! Also check out Y! You'll love it! And Z! Is that a security guard? Ok, I'm going."

October 14, 2009 9:40 AM
Anna Claire said...

I've The Little Friend first but haven't read TSH, though I've heard it's better. I have mixed feelings about TLF...I love Harriet and parts of the book were just brilliant...and then parts felt like beating a long-dead horse. Your review of TSH was beautiful and I WANT to read it.

October 15, 2009 10:12 AM
Post a Comment